Study 6: Fallacy in Dialogue
She |
"You're just like your father--lazy and sloppy!" |
AH |
He |
"You wouldn't talk that way in front of my Dad!" |
AB |
She |
"Maybe not, but I get no help from you; after 40 hours of hard
work, I do all, I mean all the house cleaning and cooking while you watch
TV?" |
AM |
He |
"All women who want both career and marriage seem to feel very
happy about doing both! That's what all successful women say." |
AP |
She |
"Would Mr. Rogers, your hero, hold the opinions you have about
marriages and careers?" |
AV |
He |
"Mr. Rogers has never argued that career and marriage are
incompatible for women. Therefore, he must believe that they are
compatible." |
AI |
She |
"Don't talk to me about Mr. Rogers. The last time you brought him
into our discussion, we had a terrible fight!" |
FC |
He |
"I didn't bring |
FD |
She |
"It's not a question of liking |
A |
He |
"This is the third time you have accused me of using what
Mr. Rogers' says. When you run out of good arguments, you always say this
about me." |
HG |
She |
"This is just like you! You conclude that you are innocent of any
wrong-doing because you are innocent of any wrong-doing!" |
CR |
He |
"When will you stop hassling me?" |
CQ |